We live in an era dominated by digital connectivity where social media platforms have become an integral part of our lives. Among the myriad of platforms, Instagram, with its visually appealing content, has become particularly popular among young users.
As per Statista, Instagram had 1.35 billion active users in 2023. In 2024, the platform is likely to see 1.4 billion active users.
Drilling into the data, it has been observed that Instagram has a lot of young users. Common Sense Media reports that kids as young as eight are using social media platforms like Instagram more than ever. However, concerns are mounting regarding the potential impact of these platforms on the mental health of children.
Recently, there has been a growing debate about whether parents can hold Instagram accountable for any harm inflicted on their children’s mental well-being. While the legal landscape is intricate and evolving, several potential avenues exist through which parents might seek legal recourse regarding this.
Let’s see how Instagram can be legally held accountable for putting children’s mental health at risk.
Read More: How To Invert Colors In Photoshop
Table of Contents
Failure to Implement Age Verification Mechanisms
According to Instagram’s terms of service, users must be at least 13 years old to create an account. However, it is widely acknowledged that many underage individuals easily sidestep these restrictions to access the platform. Last year, Ars Technica reported that Instagram is aware of underaged kids using the platform but doesn’t take necessary action to prevent this. Instead, they collect the data of these kids without parental consent.
Parents may contend that Instagram’s lax approach to age verification has facilitated their children’s premature exposure to potentially harmful content. Parents might argue that Instagram’s negligence in enforcing age restrictions directly correlates with the negative impact on their children’s mental well-being.
The platform could be held accountable for creating an environment that allows underage users access to age-inappropriate content. This potentially results in mental health issues such as anxiety, depression, or body image concerns.
Inadequate Safeguarding Measures Against Cyberbullying
According to the Pew Research Center, nearly half of US teens have been victims of cyberbullying. Over the past few years, cyberbullying has emerged as a pervasive issue on social media platforms, including Instagram.
Parents might argue that Instagram’s failure to implement effective measures to curb cyberbullying has exposed their children to harassment and online abuse. The platform’s algorithms and reporting systems may be scrutinized, with parents contending that these mechanisms are insufficient in promptly identifying and addressing cyberbullying.
Parents could argue that Instagram, as a responsible entity, should have invested more resources in developing advanced algorithms to detect and prevent cyberbullying. If it can be established that this negligence has directly contributed to their children’s deteriorating mental health, a legal case might hold ground.
Algorithmic Impact on Mental Health
The algorithms governing content visibility on Instagram are complex and not without controversy. Parents could potentially argue that Instagram’s algorithms contribute to a toxic environment. It does so by promoting content that glamorizes unrealistic beauty standards, materialism, and other potentially harmful narratives. The argument here is that constant exposure to such content might adversely affect a child’s self-esteem, body image, and overall mental health.
Proving a direct link between Instagram’s algorithms and a child’s mental health struggles can be challenging. However, parents may use expert testimonies and research studies to build a case. This was an approach used in the Camp Lejeune water contamination lawsuit.
According to TorHoerman Law, the Camp Lejeune lawsuits were filed to seek justice and compensation for the Camp Lejeune victims. The victims in question were exposed to contaminated water resulting from toxic chemicals that found their way into the area’s water supply. As a result, many of them ended up developing cancer.
The payout for Camp Lejeune lawsuits could reach up to $6.1 billion. This was made possible because research studies were used to show the connection between the cancer victims and the Camp Lejeune incident. Therefore, if such strategies worked in other lawsuits, there’s no reason why they won’t work in the ones against Instagram.
Lack of Parental Controls and Monitoring Features
Parents might contend that Instagram’s insufficient parental controls and monitoring features contribute to their children’s vulnerability to harmful content. Of course, Instagram does offer some tools for parents to manage their children’s accounts, such as using privacy settings and restricting certain content. However, critics argue that these features fall short of providing comprehensive safeguards.
In a legal context, parents could assert that Instagram should bear the responsibility of developing and maintaining effective parental control tools. It needs to be demonstrated that the absence of robust controls correlates with their children’s exposure to detrimental content and subsequent mental health issues. That way, Instagram may be held accountable for its alleged negligence in this regard.
Invasion of Privacy and Data Exploitation
The issue of privacy invasion and data exploitation is a recurring concern on social media platforms. The argument here is that Instagram’s data collection practices contribute to a heightened risk of children being exposed to harmful content. This content, in turn, negatively impacts their mental health. The argument could extend to the platform’s alleged failure to adequately protect user data, leading to potential exploitation by third parties.
If a legal case unfolds along these lines, parents might contend that Instagram’s business practices directly infringe upon their children’s privacy and well-being. Instagram could be held accountable for not implementing robust measures to protect user data and allowing advertisers to exploit the vulnerabilities of young users.
Failure to Provide Adequate Mental Health Support
Instagram, like many social media platforms, has taken steps to address mental health concerns by introducing features such as content warnings and support resources. However, parents could argue that these efforts by Instagram are insufficient. The platform must do more in terms of providing accessible and effective mental health support for its users.
In a lawsuit, parents might assert that Instagram’s failure to invest adequately in mental health resources demonstrates a lack of commitment to user well-being. A legal case might be constructed on the grounds of Instagram’s alleged neglect in providing comprehensive mental health support.
In conclusion, the prospect of parents suing Instagram for their children’s degrading mental health is a complex issue. While the legal landscape is still evolving, several potential avenues, like the ones discussed above, exist through which parents might seek accountability. These avenues, while difficult to explore, still hold a lot of merit if you’re seriously looking to take legal action against the platform.